Reviews

The film is explicit in its depiction of the Russo-Ukrainian war, specifically the early stages of Russia’s offensive in February 2022, and provides pointed social commentary on Russian-Ukrainian relations and the West’s role in the conflict. Stylistically, however, the film serves more as a vehicle for expressing the universal threats that armed conflict poses to civilian life.

Beyond the sporadic references to real-world events, the central focus remains on two characters trapped within the four walls of their newly acquired, expected-to-be happy home. This sense of confinement makes the story easily transposable to other military conflicts. It is precisely this claustrophobia that brings out the film’s strongest qualities, as director Zhanna Ozirna exhibits great care in capturing the stillness and quietude of the setting to heighten the prevailing sombre mood of the siege.

However, the film falters when its perspective shifts from the external conflict to the internal struggles of the couple. These tensions feel trivial and futile in light of their dire situation. This narrative turn culminates in upsetting behaviour and questionable decision-making by the characters in relation to their environment.

More »

Having only read the synopsis and not the original book, the tone and focus of the film come as an unexpected surprise. Instead of a survival tale, it presents a family drama that explores the value we place on our own lives and those of others.

The story unfolds through an unconventional structure that keeps you on your toes, making you question whether certain scenes are real or imagined. A delicate piano score preserves the tenderness at the heart of the plot, even though it’s paired with an underwhelming twofold love story.

Several scenes suffer from overacting by three of the four lead actors. The sole consistent performance is delivered by Ramzy Bedia, whose outwardly stoic yet inwardly caring portrayal of the arbiter stands well above the standard set by his companions.

More »

In-between being a documentary, a fiction, and even just a behind the scenes look to the making of a movie, this is for sure an innovative approach to filmmaking.

Nevertheless, this mix proposed by Kaouther Ben Hania can also be a bit perceived like a macabre social experiment for which it makes you wonder if it the experiment is worth the making considering the pain that it causes to everyone involved (both for the real people, as well as the professional actors).

The drama and intensity of the story surely gets strengthen as we move forward and we transition from the experiences of the mother to those of the daughters.

Concurrently, it is noteworthy how actually uncomfortably and bravely comedic it is the film at times considering its unsettling subject matter.

More »