Title: The Holdovers
Year: 2023
Running Time: 133′
Country: United States of America
Directed by: Alexander Payne
Written by: David Hemingson
Starring: Paul Giamatti; Da’Vine Joy Randolph; Dominic Sessa; Carrie Preston; Brady Hepner; Ian Dolley
© 2023 Miramax / CAA Media Finance.
Review by Guifré Margarit i Contel | 20 October 2023
Except for Mary (portrayed excellently by Da’Vine Joy Randolph), it’s challenging to appreciate the other rather despicable characters. Although they are presented as flawed but endearing, they come across as unlikable or ‘assholish’. Having unlikable characters isn’t an issue, but it becomes problematic when it’s clear that this wasn’t the writer’s intention.
Simultaneously, the structure of David Hemingson’s script feels extremely uneven. The first act is entirely discardable. In the second act, we encounter the problem with the characters, as only one out of three is actually likable. The third act delivers as a redemption arc for our characters, but by this point, we don’t care for their redemption as we haven’t been able to connect with them in the previous developments.